Gigabyte W291-Z00 Review an AMD EPYC GPU Tower Server

4
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Front And Three Quarter
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Front And Three Quarter

Our Gigabyte W291-Z00 review will show why this GPU tower server is unique in the market. Utilizing a single AMD EPYC CPU, the server offers capabilities in a form factor that were previously unobtainable in the market. Headlining the feature list is support for up to four passively cooled GPUs. The Gigabyte W291-Z00 has a cooling system designed to support cooling high-end GPUs in a tower form factor. In this review, we are going to cover what the system offers, along with some of the trade-offs that Gigabyte’s design team needed to make in order to match the tower form factor.

Gigabyte W291-Z00 Hardware Overview

The Gigabyte W291-Z00 is a pedestal tower server that has a primary focus: house up to four GPUs. Looking at the exterior of the server, we see a front panel dominated by air inlets. That will be a design theme of the server that we will see throughout.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Front And Three Quarter
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Front And Three Quarter

Four front 3.5″ bays provide hot-swap storage for hard drives or SATA SSDs. One can re-wire these to accept SAS drives, however, if one is using four double-width GPUs the most likely configuration is with SATA.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Drive Bays And Air Vents
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Drive Bays And Air Vents

Beneath the hot-swap bays are two massive air inlet conduits that feed the system’s 120mm fans.

Powering the server are two hot-swappable 1.6kW 80Plus Platinum power supplies. We are going to have power consumption figures later in this review, but the system is fully capable of utilizing such large power supplies.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Power Supply
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Power Supply

The rear of the chassis is surprisingly spartan. Along with the redundant power supplies, there is a massive 120mm fan along with an array of expansion slots.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Rear
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Rear

Rear I/O panel is fairly simple at its heart consisting of standard features. These include dual 1GbE networking ports and a management Ethernet port. There are also two USB 3.0 headers as well as a VGA port for local operations teams to use. The two buttons are an ID button alongside a power button. Not all servers have those features.

Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Rear IO
Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Rear IO

Opening the chassis is a needlessly complicated affair. Gigabyte uses standard screws to affix the side panel. We would have, at a minimum, like to have seen thumb screws used. Even lower-end tower servers, like the Dell EMC PowerEdge T340 and PowerEdge T140 utilize smooth latching mechanisms. The Gigabyte W291-Z00 is a purpose-built machine and that means one does not get some of the more refined features we see in other servers.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Internal And Rear
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Internal And Rear

At the heart of the Gigabyte W291-Z00 is the MZ01-CE1 motherboard. You can read our full Gigabyte MZ01-CE1 review. This motherboard provides most of the functionality of the Gigabyte W291-Z00 and shapes how the system can be expanded.

Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Overview 1
Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Overview 1

The platform supports a single AMD EPYC 7000 series CPU along with eight DIMMs allowing for full 8-channel memory bandwidth. In the Gigabyte W291-Z00, there is a heatsink cooling solution with copper heat pipes. This solution exhausts air both to the back of the chassis like in a standard server, but also towards the front of the chassis, against the main airflow. Using 180W CPUs, as the system was specified for, we had no cooling issues. Moving to the AMD EPYC 7371 at over 200W TDP, we saw some CPU thermal throttling. Since we tried that which was out of the spec range, we are going to recommend you follow Gigabyte’s configuration guidelines.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 CPU Cooler
Gigabyte W291 Z00 CPU Cooler

The real standout feature of this motherboard is its PCIe lanes. There are four PCIe x16 slots as well as a PCIe x8 slot.

Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 PCIe Clean
Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 PCIe Clean

Many of the early AMD EPYC motherboards were designed in ways which blocked using larger PCIe x16 devices, like GPUs, due to placement around the DIMM slots.

One can also find a M.2 slot capable of up to M.2 22110 (110mm) NVMe SSD installation. That larger size accommodates datacenter NVMe SSDs like the Samsung drive below that has PLP. It also allows for devices like the Intel Optane 905P 380GB M.2 NVMe SSD to be used.

Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 NVMe Installed
Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 NVMe Installed

Spacing on the Gigabyte W291-Z00 PCIe slots is set to accommodate double-width GPUs. Here is a glimpse of what that enables, housing four NVIDIA Tesla V100 32GB PCIe cards.

Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Installed With 4x Tesla V100
Gigabyte W291-Z00 Installed With 4x Tesla V100

Unlike competitive solutions, the Gigabyte W291-Z00 has the ability to cool these passive GPUs thanks to those large front fans and a custom-crafted air duct.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Passive Cooling Airflow Guide
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Passive Cooling Airflow Guide

The GPUs are held in place by a chassis retention bar. Four retention brackets keep the GPUs supported during transit and during operation.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Support Bar
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Support Bar

For traditional storage, the Gigabyte W291-Z00 has four SlimSAS ports each providing (despite the SAS name) four SATA III 6.0gbps ports. One can connect sixteen drives without utilizing a HBA which saves significant costs over Intel Lewisburg solutions.

Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Slim SAS Storage
Gigabyte MZ01 CE1 Slim SAS Storage

Briefly, we wanted to mention right angle connectors. As you may have seen, the four SlimSAS (SATA) headers, the USB 3.0 front panel header, the front panel switch and LED header, along with the ATX and aux power connectors are all mounted parallel to the motherboard’s surface. This design allows for four large GPUs to be installed and not block the physical connectivity of the connectors. It also means that a trade-off was made

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Fan Wall And Connectors
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Fan Wall And Connectors

There are a few minor items we wanted to point out in the design. First, the chassis feet swivel out to provide lateral stability to the Gigabyte W291-Z00. Made of hard plastic, we feel that these could have been rubberized potentially cutting down on some of the noise.

Gigabyte W291 Z00 Tower Feet
Gigabyte W291 Z00 Tower Feet

In our test Gigabyte W291-Z00 system, we realized this once we had installed over $40,000 of GPUs. We had configured a $50,000 system that was stuck with 1GbE networking. We would have preferred if Gigabyte found a way to make that PCIe x8 slot usable perhaps with an OCP mezzanine riser or just about anything to improve the networking situation.

Next, we are going to look at the system topology before moving onto the rest of our review. In GPU servers, like the Gigabyte W291-Z00, topology is a major talking point.

1
2
3
4
5
6
REVIEW OVERVIEW
Design & Aesthetics
9.1
Performance
9.4
Feature Set
9.2
Value
9.6
SHARE
Previous articleNew MikroTik CRS 10GbE and 40GbE Switches for 2019
Next articleIntel CXL Compute Express Link Interconnect Announced
Patrick has been running STH since 2009 and covers a wide variety of SME, SMB, and SOHO IT topics. Patrick is a consultant in the technology industry and has worked with numerous large hardware and storage vendors in the Silicon Valley. The goal of STH is simply to help users find some information about server, storage and networking, building blocks. If you have any helpful information please feel free to post on the forums.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Why not the MZ31? what, slightly larger dimensions?

    https://www.gigabyte.com/us/Server-Motherboard/AMD-EPYC-7000

    Gigabyte MZ31-AR0, 180w tdp, two SFP+, 16 RDIMM’s, PCIe 3.0 four x16 & three x8

    Gigabyte MZ01-CE1, 180w tdp, two 1GbE, 8 RDIMM’s, PCIe 3.0 four x16 & one x8

    Excellent and thorough review as usual. Love the tag
    “the Gigabyte W291-Z00 … the only option … is the best option.” Lol 8)

  2. Thanks for this review, Patrick! Great info. I don’t suppose you have four mi60’s kicking about? An all AMD test would be very cool.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here