StarTech SATSASBAY425 Hot Swap SSD 4-in-1 2.5″ to 5.25″ Review

7
Posted May 8, 2012 by Patrick Kennedy in Servers

Today we are looking at the StarTech SATSASBAY425 which is a 4-in-1 2.5″ drives to 5.25″ drive bay hot swap unit great for SSDs. As SSD prices fall, it becomes more likely that users will turn to RAID 0, RAID 1 or RAID 10 arrays to provide extra speed, redundancy and/ or capacity. Personally, I have had at least three SSDs in my main workstation for two years now. Recently Thermaltake sent its 4-in-1 solution, the Thermaltake MAX-1542 hotswap enclosure that puts four 2.5″ hot swap drive bays into a single 5.25″ drive slot. Long time readersof this site may remember I used similar 4-in-1 devices with my old 8x 15K rpm SAS setup. At that point I used  two Athena Power 4-in-1 hotswap enclosures but came away thinking that they were not the best in terms of noise, especially cooling 15,000 rpm 2.5″ SAS drives. Let’s see how the Startech SATSASBAY425 compares to the other units.

Test Configuration

The test configuration for this series is going to be my single-processor LGA 2011 test bed.

  1. CPU(s): Intel Core i7-3930K
  2. Motherboard: ASUS P9X79 WS
  3. Memory: 32GB (8x 4GB) G.Skill Ripjaws X DDR3 1600
  4. Drives: Corsair Force3 120GBOCZ Vertex 3 120GB 2x OCZ Agility 3 120GB
  5. Chassis: Corsair Carbide Series 500R
  6. SSD Hotswap Enclosure: StarTech SATSASBAY425 4x 2.5″ in 1x 5.25″ bay enclosure
  7. Power Supply: Corsair AX850 850w 80 Plus Gold

Overall, this provides a good mix of drive connectivity alongside a fairly fast test platform. Personally, I like to label trays to ensure I know exactly which controller they are hooked into and what drive or RAID array they belong to in the OS. Being able to easily trace hardware to software layers is always a best practice.

The StarTech SATSASBAY425

Traditionally 5.25″ bays were a common hard drive form factor until about the days of the Quantum Bigfoot in the mid-1990′s. Since then the 5.25″ bays have been normally reserved for full size optical drives. With hot swap drive enclosures, these 5.25″ bays can be re-purposed to accommodate either 3.5″ or 2.5″ drives. Using 4-in-1 and 6-in-1 enclosures, a user can get much higher drive densities out of traditional server and tower enclosures when using 2.5″ drives. The StarTech SATSASBAY425 itself looks really sleek with a black enclosure accented by a little bit of blue on its plastic door levers.

Startech SATSASBAY425 Front View

Startech SATSASBAY425 Front View

Once can see a very stylish front area and that there are clear channels for airflow along both the top and bottom portions of each drive. This gets some substantial airflow moving through the chassis.

Startech SATSASBAY425 Internal

Startech SATSASBAY425 Internal

As one can see, the rear of the enclosure is optimized for airflow. The PCBs that distribute power and route the SATA connections are clearly visible in the rear of the enclosure and the connector shows it accepts both SAS and SATA disks.

Startech SATSASBAY425 Front Tray

Startech SATSASBAY425 Front Tray

Hot-swap drive bays make it easy to swap disks out. One can simply push the blue latch, swing out the handle and pull out the drive. This makes replacing a drive in the event of a RAID failure very simple.

Startech SATSASBAY425 Drive Tray

Startech SATSASBAY425 Drive Tray

The drive tray seen here is very similar to the Thermaltake MAX-1542 except for two important differences. First, the top portion is made of metal. Second the StarTech version screws securely in place while the Thermaltake version uses a plastic locking mechanism. Since neither allow for tool-less drive insertion, the StarTech version is probably more secure which is a good thing.

Startech SATSASBAY425 Rear

Startech SATSASBAY425 Rear

The rear of the chassis shows four 7-pin SAS/ SATA connectors. From most motherboards this is a very simple 7-pin to 7-pin connector. If you are using a RAID controller or HBA such as an IBM M1015, you would use a SFF-8087 to 7-pin break out cable to connect this enclosure to the RAID controller. Common misconceptions are that most of these hot swap / RAID controllers provide RAID functionality or special enclosures are needed to run drives in RAID. This is not the case since these days most hot swap / RAID controllers are made to pass-through disks providing only housing, a data channel, cooling and power. StarTech also utilizes a standard 4-pin Molex connector which makes it compatible with most power supplies.

Conclusion

Overall, for those looking at a consumer 4-in-1 for solid state drives, the StarTech SATSASBAY425 is a solid choice. It is fairly  quiet which is much better than those units intended mainly for 15K RPM drives and servers. For those users that want hot-swap SSD trays and have limited space, this is an excellent option as it does easily expand an enclosure and allows for rapid drive slots. I again tried nine different drives in the enclosure and all fit without issue. I did like the fact that StarTech opted for less plastic and less metal and that they did address the highly eye-popping red color of the Thermaltake units by moving to a small bit of  blue accents. Just looking at the all black Carbide 500R chassis the small blue latches look interesting but not overpowering. Two of these can be used with an inexpensive controller such as the IBM M1015 or other LSI SAS 2008 controller to get a nice eight drive 6.0gbps subsystem. I would love to see one of these in a tool-free version one day which would make replacing SSDs in RAID arrays trivial.

Startech SATSASBAY425 Summary

Startech SATSASBAY425 Summary


About the Author

Patrick Kennedy

Patrick has been running ServeTheHome since 2009 and covers a wide variety of home and small business IT topics. For his day job, Patrick is a management consultant focused in the technology industry and has worked with numerous large hardware and storage vendors in the Silicon Valley. The goal of STH is simply to help users find some information about basic server building blocks. If you have any helpful information please feel free to post on the forums.

7 Comments


  1.  
    Pig lover

    I’ve used these StarTech 4 in 1s before and really found them wanting. The trays are flimsy, alignment between the drive and the sara backplane is dodgy at best and the fans are failure prone…

    The SuperMicro 4 in 1 2.5in is really not that much more expensive and it is superior in every way.




  2.  
    Jorge Alverez

    I bought one a few weeks back. Adding the screw to the top bracket gives the sleds more rigidity and have no issues sliding. Maybe this is a newer version since I had an older unit that have the sliding issues. Where I live the supermicro is mas expensive.




  3.  
    Guus

    I was looking for a 4 bay 2,5″ bay last year and had a look on the startech as well. I found out these are produced and sold under a variety of labels. Construction and used materials (2 4×4 fans) looked a bit weak and airflow seems ineffeicient for high performance 10k / 15k sas drives to me. So I went for the Raidsonic (http://www.raidsonic.de/en/products/backplanes.php?we_objectID=6804).




  4.  
    Tommy Wins

    I have a st 425 and like it much. Never problems with my raid array on it




  5.  
    Amit's Comments

    Pig — no fan failures out of ten of these I have in norco servers. Is your power supply good?




  6.  
    theak

    I have two. ok for the price. unit price matters most when many pieces are purchased. wish it had tray locks tho




  7.  
    Gianni

    Got one after reading this.

    Pros = inexpensive, decent airflow, not too noisy, trays slide fine

    Cons = no latch locks, plastic latches and facade

    I will likely pickup two more soon

    Will you review the SATSAS225ODD or SATSAS425BK looks like they have locks? What abt the USB 3.0 docks?





Leave a Response

(required)


Newly Reviewed
 
  • Western Digital Red 5TB 6TB Launch
  • Amazon T2 Instances and Intel C2550 time comparison
  • 9.6
    ASUS P9A-I-C2550-SAS-4L-Overview
  • 9.3
    Supermicro X9SKV-1125 Overview
  • Three Western Digital Red 3TB Drives SATA Side
  • Intel Xeon E5 Box Bunny