Supermicro SC842TQ-665B 4U Rackmount Hotswap Chassis Review

1
Posted March 16, 2011 by Patrick Kennedy in Servers

Supermicro contacted me about reviewing their SC842TQ-665B chassis a few weeks ago and I thought it would be a good departure from the pure storage chassis.  Sometimes, a large 4U 20-24 3.5″ bay enclosure is unnecessary. With today’s 3.5″ disk prices, adding a 4TB usable  RAID 6 array plus hot spare and a few SSDs for caching in ZFS L2ARC style configurations can be a very viable alternative when massive amounts of raw storage are not needed. The SC842TQ-665B has a mix of hot-swap bays, 5.25″ expansion bays, and solid cooling all in a small, 20.5″ deep, chassis.

Test Configuration

I detailed the dual Xeon processor build in an earlier dual processor test bed build log piece. I will note, the motherboard was a very tight fit as it is a large board and it is not on Supermicro’s compatibility list for the SC842TQ-665B. It took a bit of careful maneuvering, but everything did fit.

  1. CPU: Dual Intel Xeon E5606
  2. Motherboard: Supermicro X8DTH-6F
  3. Memory: 24GB ECC DDR3 1066MHz DRAM (6x 4GB UDIMMs)
  4. OS Drive: OCZ Agility 2 120GB
  5. Additional NICs: Intel E10G41AT2, Mellanox MHEA28-XTC, and Supermicro AOC-STGN-i2S
  6. Additional RAID Controllers/ HBAs: LSI 9211-8i, IBM ServeRAID M1015, Areca 1680LP
  7. Enclosure: Supermicro SC842TQ-665B
  8. Power Supply: Supermicro 665w (included in the SC842TQ-665B)

I intentionally used quite a few passively cooled cards to see if the case’s airflow was sufficient to cool the cards.

Features

Drive expansion is not an ultra-dense 4U configuration, but does provide quite a bit of expandability. Five hot swap 3.5″ SAS/ SATA drive bays occupy the middle portion of the front bezel. Next to these are three 5.25″ empty bays and at the lower right portion of the front bezel a slim optical drive bay can be found. The left side of the chassis has a 92mm x 38mm PWM fan that is hot swappable. In the lower middle portion there is a slick LED place with things such as dual NIC LEDs and an overheat LED.

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Front Chassis View

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Front Chassis View

Drive carriers are the side rail types so mounting 2.5″ drives in the 3.5″ hot swap bays will require an adapter. I had no issues installing five drives and sliding them in easily so it seems, at least on the test unit, that the workmanship is good in this area, and on-par with some of the storage centric Supermicro chassis reviewed previously on this site.

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Drive Caddy View

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Drive Caddy View

The 3.5″ hot swap bays support SGPIO (two ports) which allows one to see which drive failed via the LEDs associated with each 3.5″ slot.  On the flip side, the backplane accepts two 4-pin Molex style connectors and five standard 7-pin SAS/ SATA connectors. Since the Supermicro X8DTH-6F supports SGPIO this was easy to connect.

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Internal Front Facing Shot

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Internal Front Facing Shot

Also pictured above are the three 5.25″ bays which can be used for optical drives and/ or mobile racks on the left side of the picture. The bottom left shows the slim CD/DVD carrier among the power supply cables. On the right side of the above picture one can see the hot swap 92mm fan that has a duct redirecting half of the airflow to the center of the chassis. This helps more evenly distribute air to the center of the chassis since there is no room in such a short chassis for a mid-chassis fan partition.

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Front Hot Swap Fan

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Front Hot Swap Fan

That 92mm fan is easy to remove by simply pushing in a plastic clip and pulling the unit out. Two big points here are that it is very easy to service the fan in the event of failure, and the assembly did not buzz despite being a rotating part that is easily removable. One can see the importance of this fan by looking at the overall interior layout of the chassis.

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Internal Chassis View

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Internal Chassis View

One will notice that the power supply fan pulls air from the front of the chassis exhausting in the rear. The front removable fan mentioned earlier pushes air through all of the expansion slots due to the ducting. This setup worked well as even being stressed, none of the expansion cards overheated during testing. Dual mid-line 80mm x 38mm PWM controlled fans exhaust air from the part of motherboards usually occupied by RAM and either one or two CPUs.

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Rear Hot Swap Fans

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Rear Hot Swap Fans

The two rear fans are also hot swappable without opening the chassis as they are held in place by large plastic clips and remove to the rear exterior of the chassis. One can see by the above picture that the removal process involves pressing firmly on the top clip then pulling the unit away from the chassis. This was a very quick procedure. Just to give an idea of the rear exhaust profile of the case, here is a rear chassis shot:

 

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Rear Chassis View

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Rear Chassis View

As one can see, the rear of the chassis (note the motherboard I/O backplate area is open here) is designed to be one giant exhaust surface. I have had the system under near 100% average CPU utilization on the dual processors and running expansion card tests over the past few weeks. The system has been rock-solid never once throwing an overheat alarm, becoming unstable, or having a RAID controller or 10Gb NIC overheat and perform erratically.

For those wondering what the blue plastic bits are above the seven expansion slots, they are locking devices to secure expansion cards.

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Expansion Slot Locks

Supermicro SC842TQ-665B Expansion Slot Locks

Included in the SC842TQ-665B is a 665w 80+ bronze certified power supply. Perhaps one of the most interesting features of this power supply is that it comes with dual CPU 8-pin power connectors as well as PCIe connectors for GPUs. The power supply has fixed cables, so if a GPU is not being used for example, one needs to tie down the cables inside the chassis. Supermicro does provide cable management ties which makes this a bit easier. While power supply manufacturers are touting 1kW and higher designs, I will note that full of five 7,200rpm drives, eight solid state drives, 24GB of memory, two CPUs and six expansion cards did not cause the power supply to be overly taxed. If a user requires more power, there is a slightly more expensive SC842TQ-885B

From a noise perspective, the experience with the SC842TQ-665B varied greatly. The X8DTH-6F has ample 4-pin fan connectors so at startup the fans would run at full speed and generate a lot of noise. Once the system got going, the fan speed decreased as did the noise. It is certainly not quiet enough to be a desktop, but could be used in a closet rack in a small business just as easily as it could be installed in a data center.

Conclusion

Overall, the Supermicro SC842TQ-665B provides a compact, well designed server chassis which balances expandability, size, noise, and ease of maintenance to yield something that is both user friendly and relatively cost effective. The entire package retails for just over $300 which is very competitive with a 4U barebones rack mount case, power supply, and a 5-in-3 mobile rack. The difference is that the SC842TQ-665B integrates everything fairly well with features like hot-swap fans which make maintenance easy.

Feel free to discuss this article on the ServeTheHome.com forums!


About the Author

Patrick Kennedy

Patrick has been running ServeTheHome since 2009 and covers a wide variety of home and small business IT topics. For his day job, Patrick is a management consultant focused in the technology industry and has worked with numerous large hardware and storage vendors in the Silicon Valley. The goal of STH is simply to help users find some information about basic server building blocks. If you have any helpful information please feel free to post on the forums.

One Comment


  1.  

    I really like SuperMicro chassis but this model provides no way to mount drives in their 3 5.25″ bays. No brackets, no rails and no screw holes. Their tech support which is normally wonderful, has no idea how to mount the drives. – Strange!





Leave a Response

(required)


Newly Reviewed
 
  • Intel 730 480GB SSD - Power Capacitors
  • Intel 730 SSD
  • SanDisk CloudSpeed 1000E
  • Intel 730 SSD
  • Intel DC P3700 400GB Internal View
  • AppliedMicro X-Gene